NEW Devon CCG abandons plans to ration hearing aids! Four reasons why this decision would have breached the CCG’s statutory duties.

Image of Sarah Collinson, NDCS Regional Director for the South West

Sarah Collinson, Regional Director for the South West

The North East and West (NEW) Devon CCG has confirmed that it has abandoned its decision to ration deaf patients over the age of 18 to just one NHS hearing aid. The policy to restrict hearing aids had been announced in an ‘Urgent and Necessary Measures’ notice issued in December and was intended to affect all adult hearing aid users in the NEW Devon CCG area; the only exceptions would be people with additional sensory disabilities and patients with conditions such as autism ‘where social cues may be particularly important.’

As NDCS supports young deaf people into early adulthood and campaigns for all deaf children and young people to have access to good quality audiology care, the NEW Devon CCG’s moves called for a swift response, not only because it was due to be introduced with immediate effect, but also because other cash-strapped CCGs might be considering similar measures and would be watching the Devon situation closely.

With local campaign action by NDCS members, regional TV news coverage and letters to the CCG and local MPs, we pulled out all the stops to try to convince the CCG to think again. Along with pressure from Ben Bradshaw MP and Action on Hearing Loss, our action seemed to pay off, with the CCG announcing shortly before Christmas that it would suspend the decision to ration hearing aids until the issue had been considered by its Clinical Policy Committee (CPC).

When I discovered that the CCG’s Governance Committee was to look at the issue again in early January, I sent a second letter to the CCG’s Chair outlining our concerns with the proposed policy and highlighting a number of key areas where it would seem to breach the CCG’s statutory duties under the NHS Constitution and the Health and Social Care Act (HSCA). This additional pressure has borne fruit, as just a few days after looking at the issue again, the CCG has announced a complete U-turn, with the rationing of hearing aids now entirely shelved.

In case other CCG’s might have been thinking of restricting adults’ hearing aids in this way, it’s worth highlighting the main reasons why they would be wrong to do so, as I pointed out to the NEW Devon CCG:

  • The CCG is duty-bound under the NHS Constitution and the HSCA to promote equality through the services that it provides and to pay particular attention to groups or sections of society where improvements in health are not keeping pace with the rest of the population. Deaf young adults are already significantly more likely to suffer mental health problems and face higher barriers to education; deaf people are four times more likely to be unemployed that hearing people. Any measure that will compromise their ability to use their hearing as effectively as possible will exacerbate these risks and disadvantage them further.
  • Patients have the right to expect local decisions on funding of treatments to be made rationally following a proper consideration of the evidence. NEW Devon claimed in the Urgent and Necessary Measures notice issued in December that ‘Evidence suggests that correcting hearing in the second ear … is far less cost-effective even though people derive some benefit from it.’ Yet, for 20 years or more, binaural aiding has been universally accepted as the most appropriate and effective treatment for the majority of cases of bilateral hearing loss. Not only would we dispute the apparent cost-savings to be made for the CCG, but we can’t accept that one hearing aid is as good as two. In fact, there is evidence that bilaterally deaf hearing aid users are disadvantaged if they have to rely on one-sided hearing. Hearing with just one ear or one hearing aid leads to problems for the brain processing sounds, understanding speech in background noise and localising the source of a sound.
  • The NHS Constitution also gives patients the right to be given information about the risks of treatment options available. The CCG’s Urgent and Necessary Measures notice didn’t mention the risks of one-sided aiding for people who are deaf in both ears. This would have to be taken into account in any comparative cost-benefit analysis of providing one hearing aid instead of two. Quite apart from the heightened risk of mental health problems and other comorbidities, there is also a risk of monaural aiding of bilaterally deaf people doing harm to the patient by causing non-reversible auditory deprivation to the unaided side. In a significant number of patients, auditory deprivation has been found to be significant and irreversible, and it isn’t possible to predict which patients are likely to be affected in this way.
  • The Health and Social Care Act stipulates that the CCG must make arrangements to ensure that individuals to whom the services are being provided are involved in the development and consideration of proposals where the proposals would have an impact on how services are delivered or the range of health services available. To our knowledge, the CCG conducted no consultation with patients and other stakeholders on possible hearing aid rationing prior to issuing the Urgent and Necessary Measures notice in December. The lack of transparency around the Quality and Equality Impact Assessment that should have been undertaken in advance of making any decisions on this issue  is very worrying, particularly given the substantial negative impacts that hearing aid rationing would have on large numbers of deaf people  across Devon.

We are relieved at NDCS the restriction on provision of NHS hearing aids has been abandoned in Devon, at least for now. However, we will have to remain vigilant going forward, not only in Devon but also nationally, in case other CCGs seek to address financial shortfalls with similarly crude and potentially harmful rationing measures.

2 thoughts on “NEW Devon CCG abandons plans to ration hearing aids! Four reasons why this decision would have breached the CCG’s statutory duties.

  1. It is impossible to understand why the CCG thought it was OK to provide 2 hearing aids to a child from 0 – 19 years and then take one away after the age of 19 years. It is not ethical, it is not good medical practice, it reduces life chances of the young person and would very likely serve to increase overall public spending .

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s